Almost every baseball fan I know thinks the MLB playoffs drag on for far too long. We always refer to the baseball postseason simply as “October” because for 100 years the regular season ended as the calendar flipped to the 10th month of the year. These days what we call “October” actually goes into “November” because of the added rounds of the postseason tournament and all the off-days built into the schedule. This is goofy for several reasons, not the least of which is the fact that you have guys playing a summertime game in 40-some-degree temperatures in night games on Halloween. Oh, and by the way, they’re the most important games of the season and likely these guys’ careers and lives. Ridiculous.
So can it be changed? It’s a tough task, as there are stipulations on how it’s all done. I’ve heard a few ideas — maybe contract a few teams, ditch the Allstar Game, or go back to a 154-game schedule from the current 162-game schedule (which has been in place for about 50 years now). Or just get rid all those off days in October. The first three aren’t very realistic at all, and the fourth isn’t too realistic, either — for now. I’ve said for years that I have a few simple ideas for shortening the season — not by much, but enough to make a difference. Moreover, they’re realistic suggestions. So because I’m bored I’m going to blog my idea so I can take credit when Bud Selig steals them.
1) Start the season on the Friday before the what is now usually Opening Day.
This year MLB began on Monday, April 6. For the last few years the ESPN Sunday Night Baseball game has kicked off the season the day before everyone else. Why not start on Friday and begin the season with a three-game Friday-Saturday-Sunday series? Opening Day could be a day game on Friday afternoon, and everyone knows if you’re going to ditch work to down some beers at the game, Friday is an infinitely better day to do it. Give the marketing people all three days and call it Opening Weekend. And the showcase game could move to Thursday as a kick-off. Works for the NFL. Yes, you’ll have poor baseball weather in those early days, but we deal with that now and the individual games don’t matter as much in the first week, even if the W’s and L’s count just the same.
Total days saved so far — 3.
2) Play one double-header a month on a Sunday during May, June, July and August.
Yes, I am aware that the Player’s Union rules say no team can play more than two double headers (hit the first link above) in a single season. In my scenario those guys would just suck it up and agree to play two more. Baseball used to do this all the time. Maybe they add a rule where an off day that would come up anyway would have to fall after a double-header day. Playing the DHs in May through August means they wouldn’t fall at the beginning of the season when pitchers are just getting into a routine or during the last month when teams are making playoff runs and rotations are being set heading into October. This would be a bit of a concession for ownership, too, because it would mean four less game days, but you can’t tell me they wouldn’t be able to find a way to market and up-sell double-header days.
Total days saved so far — 7.
3) Make the postseason schedule look more like the regular season.
With a full week saved at this point, we could just let the postseason play out as it does now and end the season around Oct. 22 or 23, or about where it used to end before the Divisional round was added in the 1990s. That’s pretty good, but I think MLB could do one better and ditch the insane amount of off-days during October. It looks like an NBA schedule. Baseball is a “daily grind,” right? Then why is it that the Phillies had six days off between the NLCS and World Series when their series went five games and the ALCS went six? And this after a “snow out” in Denver in the round before. It’s dumb. I’m sure managers and pitchers love all that rest, but it isn’t true to the way the game is normally played.
The real reason for the insane gaps in scheduling is television. But baseball ratings have been going down for years. And, seriously, TBS? You can’t say you’re serious about ratings when you have the NLCS on TBS and Tim McCarver is still in the booth for Fox. Sorry, that just doesn’t compute. MLB is actually smart about using the Web with things like Game Day and the the At-Bat iPhone App. People have ways of keeping tabs on baseball that don’t include TV these days. MLB should beef up streaming capabilities and even think about playing some day games again during October. Back in the day, kids would sneak radios into school to hear the daytime World Series games. These days they would be on the Web using their cell phones checking Game Day. And the circle is complete.
So that’s it. No radical changes and we can keep the Allstar Game. Now if we could just get them to stop using the ASG to determine home-field advantage for the World Series ….